Amish Baked Oatmeal Recipe - Food Lovin Family (2024)

FAQs

Why is my baked oatmeal gummy? ›

Oatmeal may become gummy or have a dry texture if the combined oat mixture sits for a prolonged time before it is baked. Once the wet ingredients are mixed with the oatmeal, the oatmeal will begin absorbing moisture. If it sits for too long, it will become dry or gummy when baked due to inadequate moisture.

The difference between baked oatmeal and baked oats is all in the texture. "And getting that cake-like texture comes from adding the egg, but also blending the ingredients well," Jawad explains. You can double (or triple) the recipe.

Storage Tips

Refrigerate leftover baked oatmeal for 5 to 7 days, either wrapped in the baking pan or in an airtight container. To Reheat. Bake the oatmeal in a 350 degree F oven until it's warmed through, or simply heat it up in the microwave.

It adds a delicious sweet and salty flavor to the oats. Greek yogurt – try a dollop on top or my Greek yogurt oatmeal. Nuts and seeds – add almonds, pecans, walnuts, sunflower seeds, chia seeds and/or flaxseed to your oats for some crunch and a touch of protein.

The texture of oatmeal can vary depending on the cooking liquid used. When cooked with water, oatmeal can become wet and somewhat slimy due to the starches released from the oats during the cooking process. Water doesn't provide the same richness and creaminess as milk, which contributes to the difference in texture.

Dry baked oats result from using too much oats or not enough liquid. You should find that this recipe yields moist and fluffy oats!

Oatmeal's high fiber content and prebiotic qualities may benefit your body in more ways than one. Making oatmeal a regular part of your menu can potentially lower your disease risk, help your gut health thrive, make bowel movements easier and keep you feeling fuller for longer.

It's also full of fiber and protein, making it a healthy breakfast option. Baked oatmeal is a great blank canvas that you can jazz up with any number of add-ins. We suggest raisins, nuts, chocolate chips, and fresh fruit, but the possibilities are truly endless.

Compare 100 calories of baked potato to 100 calories of oatmeal, and you find a bit less protein (3 grams vs. 4), a bit more starch (18 grams vs. 16) and a similar mineral profile (potatoes have more potassium, but oats have more selenium). But potatoes beat out oats in just about every vitamin, as well as fiber.

A cup of cooked oatmeal (1/2 cup of dried oats) contains approximately 30 grams of carbs, which can fit into a nutritious meal plan for people with diabetes. Oatmeal is high in fiber and nutrients but low in saturated and trans fats and sugar and can help you maintain a healthy blood sugar level.

Should you refrigerate baked oatmeal? ›

if you want to double the recipe, make it in a 9×13-inch pan and double the ingredients. Feel free to add nuts or use fresh or frozen fruit instead of the dried fruit. Store the baked oatmeal in the refrigerator for up to 7 days. You can also freeze it for up to 3 months.

Can I prepare oatmeal and leave it at room temperature overnight? As long as there's no milk or butter, leaving it at room temp is fine.

High-sugar toppings like chocolate, syrup, and dried fruit

As Best points out, "some of the worst ingredients that are mistakenly added to healthy overnight oat recipes include chocolate sauce, sugar, syrup, and dried fruit."

According to the American Kennel Club, you can typically feed dogs around one tablespoon (15 grams) of cooked oatmeal for every 20 pounds (9 kg) of body weight (16). Given its rich content of soluble fiber, oatmeal has also become an increasingly common ingredient in many types of commercial dog food ( 17 ).

This is absolutely my most common error, and it's easy to make! Luckily, it's also easy to fix. Remove from heat, add more liquid (OR yogurt), and stir. The oatmeal will probably not reach the perfect consistency you were originally going for, but it should regain most of its creamy charm!

The method is pretty simple. Instead of a 2-1 ratio of water to oats that most manufacturer's recommend, use a 1-1 ratio. Equal parts of oats and water will allow the oats to absorb all the liquid and be slightly al dente. No mush.

Oats cooked in milk tend to be gluey, sticky, and thick. Follow this tip: Cook your oats in water for the best texture. If you're hoping for a protein boost from milk (which is definitely why my dad always instructed me to cook oats in milk), add a splash after cooking.

When cooked correctly, oatmeal should have a hearty, slightly chewy texture and creamy consistency. It should never be watery or 'gluey'.